Competitive sports are not character building. They are character revealing.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/af49c/af49c540d993de5a09f47b5835692311c7dcfe63" alt=""
Instead, most of my experience with organized, competitive sports is vicarious -- as a spectator, and probably more importantly, as a mom. Those who compete and coach could argue that I don't have a right to comment about this topic. That I just don't "get" it. Perhaps. But I've been doing A LOT of observing. And I've collected TONS of completely non-scientific data on the subject.
I've been immersed in the sports culture ever since my son was old enough to kick a soccer ball and hold a bat. When my two daughters entered the sports world, my investment of time increased exponentially. I've sat in the bleachers of gyms and football and soccer fields all over southern Illinois.
We start them out young. Before they are even capable of understanding the rules of the "game" we have them out in it - running and throwing and catching and hitting - some doing it better than others, for sure.
And then we sign them up for a team. I think it begins here. Organized athletics start to reveal a bit of who we really are, our true character. We start to compare. And we start to place more value on the kids who display more skill. They are now somehow more important. Which means other kids are less important. We've now demonstrated to our kids what we truly value -- their athletic ability. It might be subtle at first, but kids get it. They know. And they remember.
Sports are only tools. They are tools consisting of balls, bats, gloves, shoulder pads, knee pads, bases, goal posts, pucks and nets. They are tools used on fields of grass, or wooden floors, or sheets of ice. They are tools with books that explain how to use them properly and what to do when they are used improperly. They are neither inherently good -- or bad.
Just like any tool, they can be used to build or to tear down. However unlike most other tools, the building up and tearing down refers to people -- human beings -- often children or adolescents. And THAT'S the problem. Too many of us don't get that.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/450eb/450ebb81784c3077d37fa8100df58560471cdab3" alt=""
Character is revealed all along the line.
Character is revealed in the coaches. Is their primary goal to develop PLAYERS, or PEOPLE? What do they value the most? At the end of the day, or the end of their coaching career, what will matter the most? The win/loss record? Or all the kids they had the privilege of knowing, who looked up to them for guidance and advice, who became better people because of them?
Character is revealed in the players. How do they treat one another? What do they say to each other in the locker room, on the bench, on the playing field? Do those with more "skill" feel more important? How do the starters treat those who sit on the bench? And how do the bench players treat the starters?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2dd4f/2dd4f86cc6f30474eaf790df8026127360737a1c" alt=""
Sports are not character building -- they are character revealing.
Sports are tools, and in the hands of the right people, those who aspire to develop good character traits, they can be very useful. People help other people develop good character. Coaches, parents, mentors, teachers, grandparents, youth pastors, friends.
I am praying that God will help me see EACH player as His priceless child, and EACH coach as God's instrument -- one who is investing a great deal of time and energy into our children. I am praying that He will constantly remind me that it really is more than just a game. Because our children are being formed and changed.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6a7cd/6a7cd2c540d3fbb16f4c4bc3f823b54f168d9011" alt=""
I am praying God will help me see all coaches, players, referees, and spectators as PEOPLE first.
People -- equally loved and valued by God. Not because of what they DO, but because of who they ARE. God's children.
And as God's children -- the playing field is completely level.